Tuesday, 24 October 2017

real analysis - Prove that if suman converges absolutely, then suma2n converges absolutely



I'm trying to re-learn my undergrad math, and I'm using Stephen Abbot's Understanding Analysis. In section 2.7, he has the following exercise:



Exercise 2.7.5 (a) Show that if an converges absolutely, then a2n also converges absolutely. Does this proposition hold without absolute convergence?



I'm posting about this here because my answer to that last question about whether the proposition holds without absolute convergence is "Yes", but my suspicions are raised by him merely asking the question. Usually questions like this are asked to point out that certain conditions are necessary in the statement of propositions, theorems, etc. I just want to see if I'm missing something here.



Anyway, here's how I prove the absolute convergence of a2n, and note that I never use the fact that an is absolutely convergent:




Proof: Let sn=ni=1a2n. I want to show that (sn) is a Cauchy sequence. So, let ϵ>0 and n>m, and consider,
|snsm|=|(a21+a22+a2n)(a21+a22+a2m)|=|(am+1)2+(am+2)2++a2n|=|am+1|2+|am+2|2++|an|2
Now, since am converges, the sequence (am) has limit 0. Therefore I can choose an N such that |am|<ϵ/n for all m>N. So for all n>m>N, we have,

|snsm|=|am+1|2+|am+2|2++|an|2<(ϵn)2+(ϵn)2++(ϵn)2<(ϵnm)2+(ϵnm)2++(ϵnm)2=ϵ
Therefore (sn) is Cauchy and a2n converges. And since a2n=|a2n|, the series a2n is absolutely convergent. ∎




Am I doing something wrong here? Am I right in thinking that an need not be absolutely convergent for a2n to be absolutely convergent?


Answer



The problem with your proof as written is that n is arbitrary, so when you choose N you are not choosing a fixed value - you need a different N for each n.



You could approach this by noting that there is an N with |am|<1 for m>N, and therefore |am|2<|am|, which sets up a comparison using the absolute convergence.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...