Key issue: For infinite sets, does the existence of a bijection mean they have the same number of elements?
For example, does the set of natural numbers N = {1,2,3,4...} have the same number of elements as the set of positive even integers E = {2,4,6,8...}? There is a one-to-one correspondence between these sets:
1 -> 2
2 -> 4
3 -> 6
...
However, depending on how you look at it, there is also an injective function (one-to-one but not onto) between E and N:
-> 1
2 -> 2
-> 3
4 -> 4
-> 5
6 -> 6
...
In this way, all of the elements in E are in N, but not all of the elements in N are in E. Does this "prove", in some way, that N and E are not equinumerous? If not, does this mean that while E is a proper subset of N, it still has the same number of members as N - something that is true for infinite sets but not true of finite sets?
A second example:
What about the following sets:
A: {a1,a2,a3,…}
B: {b1,b2,b3,…}
A has one-to-one correspondence (bijection) with B:
a1 -> b1
a2 -> b2
a3 -> b3
…
If this, bijection from A to B, shows that A and B have the same number of elements, what happens if we shift A up so that there is an injective function (one-to-one but not onto) between A and B, e.g.
? -> b1
a1 -> b2
a2 -> b3
a3 -> b4
…
Does this show that A and B do not necessarily have the same number of elements, after all - despite having bijection between them in one arrangement - since we can arrange them in such a way that there is a one-to-one function, but not onto?
No comments:
Post a Comment