Why is this rational expressions indeterminate when evaluated?

I have this rational expression to evaluate,

$${{3a-3}\over {4a(a-1)}} \text { if } a=1.$$

I understand that if you substitute 1, both the numerator and denominator would turn out 0, thus making it indeterminate. But what if I factor out the numerator $3a-3$ to $3(a-1)$ and cancel out $(a-1)$ from both the numerator and denominator, wouldn't it just give $3\over4$ as the answer?

Answer

For this function:

$$\frac{3a-3}{4a(a-1)}$$

When $a=1$ this function will not be defined at that specific x-value.

The reason is because:

$$\frac{3a-3}{4a(a-1)} = \frac{3}{4a}$$

Even though the $(a-1)$ term cancels, the function still isn't defined at that point. We call $a = 1$ to be a hole in the function.

You can read more about it here

Comment if you have any questions.