Tuesday, 3 September 2019

calculus - By Cauchy's criterion of limit, show that limxto0(sinfrac1x+xcosfrac1x) does not exist.




By Cauchy's criterion of limit (not sequencial criterion), show that limx0(sin1x+xcos1x)

does not exist.



Cauchy's criterion of limit



limxcf(x)=l iff for every ϵ>0, there exists δ such that |f(x2)f(x1)|<ϵ

for 0<|x1c|<δ and 0<|x2c|<δ.



Please suggest x2,x1 and help me to solve the problem.


Answer



One part of Cauchy's Criterion says that





RESULT: If ϵ>0 such that δ>0, we can find x1,x2 satisfying 0<|x1a|<δ and 0<|x2a|<δ but |f(x2)f(x1)|ϵ then limxaf(x) does not exist.




Let us write f(x)=sin1x+xcos1x.



Take ϵ2. Let δ>0. By Archimedean property,we can find nN such that 1n<δ. Take
x1=13π2+2πnandx2=1π2+2πn.

Notice that $0|f(x2)f(x1)|=|1(1)|=2ϵ.

Apply the result and we are done.




NOTE: That was the idea behind the hint given by @5xum. The only difference is that our delta and epsilon were interchanged. Since the OP want for clarification, I rather post an answer than to put all of these in the comments.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...