I found this exercise in Beachy and Blair:Abstract algebra:
The smallest positive solution of the congruence $ax\equiv 0 \ (mod \ n)$ is called the $\textbf{additive order}$ of $a$ modulo $n$.
Prove that if $p$ is a prime and $a$ is any integer such that $p\nmid a$, then the additive order of $a$ modulo $p$ is equal to $p$.
Here is what I did:
First of all $x=p$ is a solution but we have to show that it is the smallest positive so
assume $ax\equiv 0 \ (mod\ p)$, $p\nmid a$ and that $p$ is a prime and that we have
$$
as\equiv 0\ (mod\ p)\qquad \text{with} \ 0$$
this translates to the equation
$$
as=0+kp, \quad k\in\mathbb{Z}
$$
that is
$$
as=kp.
$$
Now since $p$ was prime we know that
$$
a\nmid p,\quad s\nmid p
$$
furthermore
$$
p\nmid a,\quad p\nmid s.
$$
So if the above equation is to stand $k$ has to divide one of the factors on the left-hand side. If we assume $k\mid a$ and $k\neq a$ then we get a factorisation of $p$ which is impossible. On the other hand if $k=a$ then we get $s=p$ again a contradiction since by assumption $s
Is this proof correct?
Is there another way not involving so many cases? (generally when I have to divide up the solution into many cases I have the feeling that I don't really grasp the question)
Answer
For two integers $a$ and $b$, if an integer c exists such that $$(b,c)=1\quad AND\quad c\mid ab$$ then $$c\mid a$$
Proof: $$(b,c)=1\Rightarrow \exists_{s,t} :\ sb+tc=1$$
$$\Rightarrow sab+tac=a$$
$$\Rightarrow c\mid a$$
So now consider the given relation $ax\equiv 0\pmod p$, or equivalently, $$p\mid ax$$
What can you say about $x$?
No comments:
Post a Comment