I would like to prove that the solutions to Cauchy's functional equation over Q are linear, that is, all solutions f:Q→Q have the property f(x)=cx for some c∈Q.
The proof is to be done in a very specific order: First, we must prove that it works for all x∈N, then for all x∈Z. Third we must show it works for all 1x where x∈Z. Finally, we must show that it works for all pq where p,q∈Z, q≠0.
I am having trouble with the third part, where I have to show it works for 1x.
Here is what I have done up to this point:
Let f be a solution to the cauchy functional equation.
We know that f(0)=c⋅0=0, as f(x)=f(0+x)=f(0)+f(x) for some number x.
Suppose x∈N and x≠0.
Then,
f(x)=f(1)+f(1)+⋯+f(1)⏟x times=x⋅f(1)=x⋅c
If x∈Z and x≠0, then we have two cases: x>0 or x<0.
For x>0, the proof with x∈N suffices.
If x<0, then we have
f(x)=f(−1)+f(−1)+⋯+f(−1)⏟x times=x⋅f(−1)=x⋅c
I don't know how to proceed with this method to show that f(1x)=cx.
Answer
The right way to proceed lies in the realization that your argument for x∈N can be extended slightly so say that if x∈N, then f(xk)=xf(k). Why? For the same reason you pointed out. If x∈N, then
f(xk)=f(k+k+⋯+k)=f(k)+⋯+f(k)=xf(k)This result is also what provides the last part of the question.
With this in hand, you're in fine shape! This is because you know f(x∗1x)=f(1)=c=xf(1x).
No comments:
Post a Comment