Wednesday, 19 December 2018

measure theory - Showing that nullmu implies forallepsilon>0, existsdelta>0 s.t. mu(A)<deltaimpliesnu(A)<epsilon



I am stuck on what I think may be the very last line of the proof I am seeking.



Let (X,B) be a measurable space which has associated with it the finite measures μ and ν s.t. νμ. I aim to show that ϵ>0, δ>0 s.t. AB,



μ(A)<δν(A)<ϵ





  1. Fix ϵ>0.


  2. For all nN, let δn=1n2.


  3. For all nN, let AnB s.t. if EB s.t. μ(E)<δn and ν(E)>ϵ, then set An=E. Otherwise, set An=B.


  4. Suppose for sake of contradiction that |{An}|=, so that no matter the δ>0, we could find a δn=1n2<δ which has associated with it a measurable An with μ(An)<δn<δ and ν(An)>ϵ.


  5. Now if we let limsupn An=S, we have (from a prior problem) that μ(S)=0 since μ is a finite measure and n=1μ(An)n=1δn=n=11n2<. Since νμ we therefore have ν(S)=0 as well.


  6. Yet ν(S)=ν(n=1n=mAm)ϵ>0 since...





and it's here where I'm stuck in the proof.


Answer



You are almost there. Notice that since ν(S)=0,
0=ν(S)=ν(n=1m=nAm)=lim
Therefore, there exists n such that
\nu(A_n) \le \nu \left( \bigcup_{m=n}^{\infty} A_m \right) < \varepsilon,

a contradiction of the choice of A_n.



I must say though that the right way to formulate this proof would be this : Suppose by sake of contradiction that the result is false, i.e. that there exists an \varepsilon > 0 such that for all \delta > 0, there is C_{\delta} \in \mathcal B with
\mu(C_{\delta}) < \delta, \quad \nu(C_{\delta}) \ge \varepsilon.
Then you can choose \delta_n = \frac 1{n^2} and A_n = C_{\delta_n} and then continue by following our steps.



Hope that helps,


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find lim_{hrightarrow 0}frac{sin(ha)}{h}

How to find \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}\frac{\sin(ha)}{h} without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...