Let A be a subset of the domain of a function f.
Why f−1(f(A))≠A.
I was not able to find a function f which satisfies the above equation.
Can you give an example or hint.
I was asking for an example function which is not addressed
here
Answer
Any noninjective function provides a counterexample. To be more specific, let X be any set with at least two elements, Y any nonempty set, u in X, v in Y, and f:X→Y defined by f(x)=v for every x in X. Then A={u}⊂X is such that f(A)={v} hence f−1(f(A))=X≠A.
In general, for A⊂X, A⊂f−1(f(A)) but the other inclusion may fail except when f is injective.
Another example: define f:R→R by f(x)=x2 for every x. Then, f−1(f(A))=A∪(−A) for every A⊂R. For example, A=[1,2] yields f−1(f(A))=[−2,−1]∪[1,2].
No comments:
Post a Comment