Wednesday, 27 January 2016

limits - limxrightarrow0+fracsin2xtanxx3x7=frac115



Can someone show me how is possible to prove that
limx0+sin2xtanxx3x7=115



but without Taylor series. One can use L'Hospital rule if necessary. I was not able.


Answer



Let the desired limit be denoted by L.



We have via LHR limx0xsinxx3=limx01cosx3x2=16

and limx0tanxxx3=limx0sec2x13x2=13
and we also have limx0sinxx=1
Multiplying the 3 limits above we get
limx0(xsinx)(tanxx)sinxx7=118limx0(xsinxtanxx2sinxsin2xtanx+xsin2x)x7=118limx0xsinxtanxx2sinxx3+x3sin2xtanx+xsin2xx7=118limx0xsinxtanxx2sinx+xsin2xx3x7sin2xtanxx3x7=118limx0sinxtanxxsinx+sin2xx2x6L=118

Our job is done if we can show that limx0sinxtanxxsinx+sin2xx2x6=1190
Multiplying (1) and (2) we get limx0xtanxx2sinxtanx+xsinxx6=118
Adding (4) and (5) we see that our proof is complete if we show that limx0xtanx+sin2x2x2x6=845
Squaring (1) we get limx0sin2x+x22xsinxx6=136
Subtracting (7) from (6) we see that proof is complete if we show that limx0tanx+2sinx3xx5=320
It is this limit which we will calculate using LHR as follows
A=limx0tanx+2sinx3xx5=limx0sec2x+2cosx35x4 (apply LHR)=limx01+2cos3x3cos2x5x4cos2x=15limx01+2cos3x3cos2xx4=15limx0(cosx1)2(2cosx+1)x4=35limx0(1cosxx2)2=351212=320



Thus the proof is complete by application of LHR three times (once in proof of (1), (2), (8) each). Also note that if you know the result (1) then result (2) can be derived from (1) by subtraction and noting that the limit limx0tanxsinxx3

can be calculated without LHR very easily. See this question. So in reality we only need two application of LHR for this problem.



Update: While dealing with limit expressions of type limx0f(x)/xn for large n (here n=7), I have often found it useful to multiply several well knows limits of type g(x)/xm with smaller values of m to get something like h(x)/xn. Expectation is that some terms of f(x) match with those of h(x) and a subtraction would cancel these terms. Also it is expected that resulting expression will be simplified to p(x)/xr when r<n. Continue this till we get very small values of exponent of x in denominator. Here for example I have reduced an expression with x7 to finally an expression with x5 in denominator. See this technique applied to limx0xsin(sinx)sin2xx6

here. Another application of the same technique can be found here as well.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...