Thursday, 16 November 2017

algebra precalculus - Why $sqrt{-1 times {-1}} neq sqrt{-1}^2$?



I know there must be something unmathematical in the following but I don't know where it is:



\begin{align}
\sqrt{-1} &= i \\ \\
\frac1{\sqrt{-1}} &= \frac1i \\ \\
\frac{\sqrt1}{\sqrt{-1}} &= \frac1i \\ \\
\sqrt{\frac1{-1}} &= \frac1i \\ \\

\sqrt{\frac{-1}1} &= \frac1i \\ \\
\sqrt{-1} &= \frac1i \\ \\
i &= \frac1i \\ \\
i^2 &= 1 \\ \\
-1 &= 1 \quad !!!
\end{align}


Answer



Between your third and fourth lines, you use $\frac{\sqrt{a}}{\sqrt{b}}=\sqrt{\frac{a}{b}}$. This is only (guaranteed to be) true when $a\ge 0$ and $b>0$.



edit: As pointed out in the comments, what I meant was that the identity $\frac{\sqrt{a}}{\sqrt{b}}=\sqrt{\frac{a}{b}}$ has domain $a\ge 0$ and $b>0$. Outside that domain, applying the identity is inappropriate, whether or not it "works."




In general (and this is the crux of most "fake" proofs involving square roots of negative numbers), $\sqrt{x}$ where $x$ is a negative real number ($x<0$) must first be rewritten as $i\sqrt{|x|}$ before any other algebraic manipulations can be applied (because the identities relating to manipulation of square roots [perhaps exponentiation with non-integer exponents in general] require nonnegative numbers).



This similar question, focused on $-1=i^2=(\sqrt{-1})^2=\sqrt{-1}\sqrt{-1}\overset{!}{=}\sqrt{-1\cdot-1}=\sqrt{1}=1$, is using the similar identity $\sqrt{a}\sqrt{b}=\sqrt{ab}$, which has domain $a\ge 0$ and $b\ge 0$, so applying it when $a=b=-1$ is invalid.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find $lim_{hrightarrow 0}frac{sin(ha)}{h}$

How to find $\lim_{h\rightarrow 0}\frac{\sin(ha)}{h}$ without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...