Sunday, 17 February 2019

elementary number theory - Simple Mersenne prime divisibility proofs



From "Fundamentals of Number Theory" by William J. LeVeque:




Mn=2n1.




Show that if n=rs, Mr divides Mn.




My proof is:




(Mn=2n1)+(n=rs)=>(Mrs=2rs1)=>(Mrs=(2r)s1)



(Mr=2r1)=>(Mr+1=2r)




Mrs=(Mr+1)s1



In the expansion of (Mr+1)s, all components are of the form MrX, except for the product of all ones. This follows from the combinatorial constraints. Therefore Mn is of the form



Mn=Mrs=Mr(X1+X2+...)+11.



Thus Mr|Mn.








I have two questions:



1) Is this proof correct/acceptable?



2) In what other ways can this problem be solved? Specifically I am interested in what other kinds of algebraic/logical/mathematical manipulations could be used.



Thanks in advance!


Answer



Note  fn:= an1 = anm(am1)+anm1,  i.e.  fn=k fm+fnmfnm(modfm) so




THEOREM Let  fn be an integer sequence with  f0=0  and  fnfnm (mod fm)  for n>m. Then  (fn,fm) = f(n,m)  where  (i,j)  denotes  gcd(i,j).



Proof   By induction on n+m. The theorem is trivially true if  n=m  or  n=0  or m=0.
So we may assume n>m>0.  Note  (fn,fm)= (fnm,fm)  follows from the hypothesis.
Since  (nm)+m < n+m,  induction yields   (fnm,fm) = f(nm,m) = f(n,m)   QED



In particular (MR,MRS)=M(R,RS)=MR  so  MR|MRS



See also this post for a conceptual proof exploiting the innate structure - an order ideal, and look up divisibility sequence to learn more about the essence of the matter.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...