While watching interesting mathematics videos, I found one of the papers of Srinivasa Ramanujan to G.H.Hardy in which he had written 13+23+33+43+⋯=1120.
The problem is that every term on the left is more than 1120 yet the sum is 1120. How is that ???
I know that there are many and much more interesting things presented by Ramanujan (like 1−1+1−1+1...=12 and 1+2+3+4.....=−112) but for now I am interested in the summation in the title.
Any idea/hint is heartily welcome. Thanks.
Here is the video I'm talking about.
Answer
I think I have rediscovered it (after watching the video you linked and read wiki biography of Ramanujan).
Start with 1x+1=1−x+x2−x3+−⋯,|x|<1.
Take a magic mushroom and, ignoring |x|<1, let us take x=1 in each one. 12=1−1+1−1+−⋯−14=−1+2−3+4−+⋯14=2⋅1−3⋅2+4⋅3−+⋯−38=−3⋅2⋅1+4⋅3⋅2−5⋅4⋅3+−⋯
But notice ∞∑m=1(−1)m+1m2=∞∑m=1(−1)m+1m(m+1)−∞∑m=1(−1)m+1m=14−14=0.
On the other hand, ζ(−3):=13+23+33+⋯24ζ(−3)=2⋅23+2⋅43+2⋅63+⋯
Recently I also found a proof of Riemann conjecture, but the answer box is too narrow for me to type all that down.
P.s. seriously, I think Ramanujan's effort is sort of finding an interpretation of divergent series so that they have a real value, while their manipulation to be still consistent to our usual notion of arithmetics: arranging, addition, expanding, etc.?
Maybe this can be compared to the attempt to define quaternion as an extension of complex numbers, while inevitably discarding commutative law?
No comments:
Post a Comment