Sunday, 6 July 2014

calculus - Is intinftyinftysinx,mathrmdx divergent or convergent?



I was determining whether



sinxdx



was divergent or convergent. So, I did the following steps:




sinxdx=0sinxdx+0sinxdx=limt(cosx|t0)+lima(cosx|0a)=limtcos(t)+cos0+limacos0+cosa=limt1cost+lima1+cosa



Now, at this point, it would be reasonable to say that both the limits are undefined and therefore, the integral is divergent but then if I try something like the following




=limt1cost+lima1+cosa=limt1cost+limacosa+1=limb1+cosbcosb+1=0



So, as you can see, it was shown before that the integral is divergent but with some manipulation, we came at an answer of 0 but is that valid? I assume, a similar technique can be applied to 1xdx.


Answer



Your first claim was correct: the limit does not exist. t and a are unrelated, so there's no good reason you should be able to set t=a=b and take a limit. For sinxdx to be defined, both 0sinxdx and 0sinxdx must exist: but as you saw, neither do.




What you calculated is instead called the Cauchy Principal Value; indeed, the Cauchy principal value of sin(x)dx

is 0 (as it is for every odd function).


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...