I was determining whether
∫∞−∞sinxdx
was divergent or convergent. So, I did the following steps:
∫∞−∞sinxdx=∫∞0sinxdx+∫0−∞sinxdx=limt→∞(−cosx|t0)+lima→−∞(−cosx|0a)=limt→∞−cos(t)+cos0+lima→−∞−cos0+cosa=limt→∞1−cost+lima→−∞−1+cosa
Now, at this point, it would be reasonable to say that both the limits are undefined and therefore, the integral is divergent but then if I try something like the following
=limt→∞1−cost+lima→∞−1+cosa=limt→∞−1−cost+lima→∞cosa+1=limb→∞−1+cosb−cosb+1=0
So, as you can see, it was shown before that the integral is divergent but with some manipulation, we came at an answer of 0 but is that valid? I assume, a similar technique can be applied to ∫∞−∞1xdx.
Answer
Your first claim was correct: the limit does not exist. t and a are unrelated, so there's no good reason you should be able to set t=a=b and take a limit. For ∫∞−∞sinxdx to be defined, both ∫0−∞sinxdx and ∫∞0sinxdx must exist: but as you saw, neither do.
What you calculated is instead called the Cauchy Principal Value; indeed, the Cauchy principal value of ∫∞−∞sin(x)dx
No comments:
Post a Comment