I was trying to prove that 3√2,3√4 and 1 are linearly independent using elementary knowledge of rational numbers. I also saw this which was in a way close to the question I was thinking about. But I could not come up with any proof using simple arguments. So if someone could give a simple proof, it would be great.
My try:
a3√2+b3√4+c=0 Then taking c to the other side cubing on both sides we get 2a3+4b3+6ab(a+b)=−c3. I could not proceed further from here.
Apart from the above question i was also wondering how one would prove that √2,√3,√5,√7,√11,√13 are linearly independent. Here assuming a√2+b√3+c√5+...=0 and solving seems to get complicated. So how does one solve problems of this type?
Answer
Let α=3√2 and suppose a+bα+cα2=0 with a,b,c∈Z, which we may assume coprime.
Then aα+bα2+2c=0 and aα2+2b+2cα=0.
This means that the matrix below is singular
(abc2cab2b2ca)
Its determinant must be zero:
a3−6abc+2b3+4c3=0
This implies that a is even: a=2A. So
4A3−6Abc+b3+2c3=0
This implies that b is even: b=2B. So
2A3−6ABc+4B3+c3=0
This implies that c is even. This contradicts they being coprime.
No comments:
Post a Comment