Wednesday, 25 February 2015

statistics - Mean concentration implies median concentration



Exercise 2.14 in Wainwright, "High-Dimensional Statistics", states that if X is such that P[|XE[X]|t]c1ec2t2, for c1,c2 positive constants, t0, then for any median mX it holds that P[|XmX|t]c3ec4t2, with c3=4c1 and c4=c2/8.



I can get some loose concentration around the median using |E[X]mX|V[X], but this does not achieve the constants proposed. Any ideas for how to get the suggested bound, or any other bound resembling it?


Answer



Let Δ=|EXmX|. The idea of the proof is that if X is too far from mean, then X is far from median as well. If it is close, then make the upper bound a triviality.




Now consider the two cases for t:




  1. t2Δ:



    which implies that t2Δ.
    By the reverse triangle inequality, |XEX||Xmx|Δ. Thus
    P(|XmX|t)P(|XmX|t2+Δ)P(|XEX|t2)c1ec2t24.



  2. t<2Δ:



    By the definition of median: 12P(|XEX|Δ)c1ec2Δ2. Therefore, 2c1ec2Δ21.
    2c1ec24t22c1ec24(2Δ)2=2c1ec2Δ21
    Therefore, the required condition holds trivially.




The final constants are c3=2c1 and c4=c24. I don't know why I am getting better constants. Let me know if you spot an error.



No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find lim without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...