Thursday, 29 December 2016

calculus - Showing that an unbounded set has an unbounded sequence



Suppose I have an unbounded set S of Real numbers.
I want to show that I can find a sequence {an} in S such that limnan=.




Here is what I have so far:



Since S is unbounded, either S is unbounded above or S is unbounded below.



Case 1: S is not bounded above



If there is no sequence {an} in S such that limnan= then there must be a number M such that n in any sequence {an} in S, anM. This implies that S is bounded by M, a contradiction.



Case 2: S is not bounded below




The same argument as Case 1.



It seems obvious to me that I can always find such sequence but then I am not satisfied with my explanation.



Any ideas? Thank you!



By the way, I'm trying to prove that a subset of the Real numbers is compact if and only if every sequence in subset has a sub-sequence converging to point in the subset.



I'm in the last part of my proof. I want to show that S is bounded and I am going to use the answer to this question to finish the proof. Thanks!



Answer



If you know that there is no sequence {an} such that limnan=+, how do you conclude that there is a number M such that all sequences are bounded by the same number M? Doesn't that assume what you are trying to prove?



That said, what you are trying to prove is as follows : Suppose S is not bounded above, then for any natural number nN,
S[n,)


Hence, we may choose any number anS[n,), and consider the sequence {an}. Can you show that this sequence must be going to ?


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...