Sunday, 10 March 2019

analysis - f(XcapY)subsetf(X)capf(Y)



In class we had the following function which I intend to prove for my own peace of mind.




Let M and N be sets and f:MN a function:
f:P(M)P(N)X{f(x)xX}


Let X,YM then:
f(XY)f(X)f(Y)

Note: In our book (Zorich Analysis) denotes a subset, not necessarily a real subset.



Question: Is f(XY)f(X)f(Y) a correct statement?



So I know that I need to show ABxAxB. I tried as follows:
f(XY)={f(x)x(XY)}



I guess for the proof to be correct I should mention here that XY because x would be a contradiction to start with. I continued like this:
x{f(x)xXxY}x{f(x)xX}x{f(x)xY}

I don't know if this step is correct or not, but it seemed like it to me, I could conclude from there that:
x{f(x)xXxY}x{f(x)xX}x{f(x)xY}xf(X)xf(Y)x(f(X)f(Y))

Would this complete the proof? Or do I also need to show that f(X)f(Y)f(XY) ?


Answer



The simple way of doing this is to show f(XY)f(X) and f(XY)f(Y), because a subset of f(X)f(Y) is the same as a subset of f(X) and f(Y). (More generally, a subset of AB is the same as a subset of A and of B.)



But both follow from the more general statement that if AB, then f(A)f(B). Indeed, any element of f(A) is of the form f(a) for some aA, whence aB, whence f(a)f(B), i.e., any element of f(A) is an element of f(B). Now apply this statement to A=XY and B=X or B=Y.



No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...