Sunday, 7 April 2019

sequences and series - Trigonometric proof stuck with induction step



I am trying to prove:
s=01(sn)!=1nn1r=0exp(cos(2rπn))cos(sin(2rπn))




We know that exp(cosθ+isinθ)=ecosθ×eisinθ=ecosθ(cos(sinθ)+isin(sinθ))



We therefore have the equivalent:
s=01(sn)!=1nn1r=0{exp(e2rπni)}ns=01(sn)!=n1r=0{exp(e2rπni)}



Where {} denotes the real part.



Attempt at induction:
Assume true for n=k Try to prove as a consequence it is true for n=k+1




1k+1(k+1)1r=0{exp(e2rπk+1i)}=1k+1k1r=0{exp(e2rπk+1i)}+1k+1{expe(2(k+1)πk+1i)}=1k+1k1r=0{exp(e2rπk+1i)}+1k+1exp(1)



Am I along the right lines here?
I having concerns given the highlighted term in red. Specifically if this was k I might have a chance at the induction step.



I have taken this from a question marked as difficult with a and so wanted to complete it naturally. (I'm preparing to teach harder material). Unfortunately there are no answers and so I can't even see if I'm on the right lines.



Any help would be gratefully appreciated.


Answer




An idea: the RHS is (the real part of) the average of the exponentials of nth-roots of unity. The LHS is a kind of lacunary series related to the exponential series. Maybe, by expanding each exponential in the RHS, many terms vanish and only one every n remains.



Credible, since every nth term has a nth power of a nth root of unity, that is, 1. The other corresponding terms of each series may give a permutation of the nth roots of unity, whose sum is zero.






To develop this idea, rewrite the RHS using ωn=exp(2iπ/n), a primitive nth root of unity, for integer n>0.



First, your RHS is Re(Sn), with




Sn=1nn1r=0exp(ωrn)=1nn1r=0(k=0ωrknk!)=1nk=0(1k!n1r=0ωrkn)



(since the double sum above is absolutely convergent, you can exchange the summations)



The inner sum is, with en,k=ωkn,



n1r=0ωrkn=n1r=0ern,k



If en,k1, then the sum is




enn,k1en,k1=(ωnn)k1en,k1=0



And if en,k=1, the sum is simply n.



Now, en,k=1 iff ωkn=1, iff k=pn for some integer p.



Thus, the entire sum is



Sn=1nk=0un,kk!




Where un,k=n if k=pn and 0 otherwise, that is



Sn=p=01(pn)!



And finally,



s=01(sn)!=1nn1r=0exp(ωrn)



By the way, taking the real part is not necessary, as we have also proved that Sn is a real number.







In a comment above, I mention an interesting integral. Actually, the RHS is trivially a Riemann sum, and by letting n and estimating the rest of the LHS after the first term (which is always 1), you get



2π0exp(cosx)cos(sinx)dx=2π



Since we have also proved the imaginary part of Sn is zero, you also get



2π0exp(cosx)sin(sinx)dx=0




But this one was actually trivial: the integrand is both odd and periodic, so its integral on a period must be 0.



Now, thinking again about this integral, putting together the real and imaginary parts, it can be rewritten Γezizdz (Γ being the unit circle), and this integral is immediately 2π by the residue theorem, so it's not that interesting.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find lim without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...