I am trying to prove:
∞∑s=01(sn)!=1nn−1∑r=0exp(cos(2rπn))cos(sin(2rπn))
We know that exp(cosθ+isinθ)=ecosθ×eisinθ=ecosθ(cos(sinθ)+isin(sinθ))
We therefore have the equivalent:
∞∑s=01(sn)!=1nn−1∑r=0ℜ{exp(e2rπni)}n∞∑s=01(sn)!=n−1∑r=0ℜ{exp(e2rπni)}
Where ℜ{} denotes the real part.
Attempt at induction:
Assume true for n=k Try to prove as a consequence it is true for n=k+1
1k+1(k+1)−1∑r=0ℜ{exp(e2rπk+1i)}=1k+1k−1∑r=0ℜ{exp(e2rπk+1i)}+1k+1ℜ{expe(2(k+1)πk+1i)}=1k+1k−1∑r=0ℜ{exp(e2rπk+1i)}+1k+1exp(1)
Am I along the right lines here?
I having concerns given the highlighted term in red. Specifically if this was k I might have a chance at the induction step.
I have taken this from a question marked as difficult with a † and so wanted to complete it naturally. (I'm preparing to teach harder material). Unfortunately there are no answers and so I can't even see if I'm on the right lines.
Any help would be gratefully appreciated.
Answer
An idea: the RHS is (the real part of) the average of the exponentials of nth-roots of unity. The LHS is a kind of lacunary series related to the exponential series. Maybe, by expanding each exponential in the RHS, many terms vanish and only one every n remains.
Credible, since every nth term has a nth power of a nth root of unity, that is, 1. The other corresponding terms of each series may give a permutation of the nth roots of unity, whose sum is zero.
To develop this idea, rewrite the RHS using ωn=exp(2iπ/n), a primitive nth root of unity, for integer n>0.
First, your RHS is Re(Sn), with
Sn=1nn−1∑r=0exp(ωrn)=1nn−1∑r=0(∞∑k=0ωrknk!)=1n∞∑k=0(1k!n−1∑r=0ωrkn)
(since the double sum above is absolutely convergent, you can exchange the summations)
The inner sum is, with en,k=ωkn,
n−1∑r=0ωrkn=n−1∑r=0ern,k
If en,k≠1, then the sum is
enn,k−1en,k−1=(ωnn)k−1en,k−1=0
And if en,k=1, the sum is simply n.
Now, en,k=1 iff ωkn=1, iff k=pn for some integer p.
Thus, the entire sum is
Sn=1n∞∑k=0un,kk!
Where un,k=n if k=pn and 0 otherwise, that is
Sn=∞∑p=01(pn)!
And finally,
∞∑s=01(sn)!=1nn−1∑r=0exp(ωrn)
By the way, taking the real part is not necessary, as we have also proved that Sn is a real number.
In a comment above, I mention an interesting integral. Actually, the RHS is trivially a Riemann sum, and by letting n→∞ and estimating the rest of the LHS after the first term (which is always 1), you get
∫2π0exp(cosx)cos(sinx)dx=2π
Since we have also proved the imaginary part of Sn is zero, you also get
∫2π0exp(cosx)sin(sinx)dx=0
But this one was actually trivial: the integrand is both odd and periodic, so its integral on a period must be 0.
Now, thinking again about this integral, putting together the real and imaginary parts, it can be rewritten ∫Γezizdz (Γ being the unit circle), and this integral is immediately 2π by the residue theorem, so it's not that interesting.
No comments:
Post a Comment