Tuesday, 17 September 2013

factorial - A clarification of a specific proof of Stirling's formula.



In this post here, I found a proof that I was intrigued by. However, I have several questions about it. Here is the proof:




A proof I found a while ago entirely relies on creative telescoping.

Since 1n21n(n+1)=1n2(n+1),



nm1n2=nm(1n1(n+1))+12nm(1n21(n+1)2)+16nm(1n31(n+1)3)16nm1n3(n+1)3

hence: ψ(m)=nm1n21m+12m2+16m3
and in a similar
fashion: ψ(m)1m+12m2+16m3130m5.

Integrating twice, we have that logΓ(m) behaves like: logΓ(m)(m12)log(m)α>m+β+112m
where
α=1 follows from
logΓ(m+1)logΓ(m)=logm.



That gives Stirling's inequality up to a multiplicative constant.



β=log2π then follows from Legendre's

duplication formula and the well-known identity:



Γ(12)=2+0ex2dx=π.





  1. How did we get from 1n21n(n+1)=1n2(n+1) to all the summation stuff?


  2. What is ψ? Where did it come from?


  3. Where did the 130m5 term come from?



  4. How does integrating twice get us to that?


  5. How do we get from logΓ(x) to n!2πnnnen?




Basically, explain it in such a way that a brussel sprout would understand it.



Thanks for any and all help!


Answer



1. n11n(n+1)(n+2) and stuffs like that are simple to compute since they are telescopic series. n11n2 does not have an obvious telescopic structure, but we may approximate 1n2 with a telescopic term, 1n(n+1), then approximate the difference 1n21n(n+1) with a telescopic term and so on, till meeting the required accuracy;




2. ψ is the digamma function, i.e. ψ(x)=ddxlogΓ(x)=Γ(x)Γ(x). By the Weierstrass product for the Γ function, ψ is related with nN1n2. So, if we are able to approximate ψ with a decent accuracy, we are also able to approximate ψ by termise integration, then logΓ by termwise integration again, then Γ by exponentiation. That is the main idea of the approach. By integrating twice we lose track of two constants, but that is not too bad since we may easily recover them at the end from the functional identities fulfilled by the Γ function;



3. The quintic term comes from approximating 1n3(n+1)3 with a telescopic term of the form Cn5C(n+1)5;



4. Already explained in 2.;



5. Already explained in 2.: n!=Γ(n+1)=explogΓ(n+1).


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...