Thursday, 10 April 2014

real analysis - Given f is continuous and f(x)=f(etx) for all xinmathbbR and tge0, show that f is constant function



This question was asked in ISI BStat / BMath 2018 entrance exam:





Let f:RR be a continuous function such that
for all xR and t0, f(x)=f(etx) Show that
f is a constant function.







My attempt:




Suppose that f is not a constant function. Then f(0)f(x0) for some x0R. We eliminate the possibilities that x0>0 and x0<0, thus proving that our assumption was wrong.



Case 1: (x0>0). Let k be any real number between f(0) and f(x0) (not inclusive). Then by the intermediate value theorem, there exists y0(0,x0) such that f(y0)=k. But f(y0)=f(eln(x0y0)y0)=f(x0) which contradicts our assumption that f(y0) was between f(0) and f(x0).



Case 2: (x0<0). Let k be any real number between f(0) and f(x0) (not inclusive). Then by the intermediate value theorem, there exists y0(x0,0) such that f(y0)=k. But f(x0)=f(eln(y0x0)x0)=f(y0), a contradiction again.






Is this proof correct? I was probably looking for a direct proof if there's any. Alternative proofs are welcome.



Answer



An alternative proof: put x=et to get f(et)=f(1) for all t0. This im plies f(x)=f(1) for all x(0,1]. Next note that f(x)=f(2x) for all x: just take t=ln(2)). You now see easily that f(x)=f(1) for all x>0. Since f(x) satisfies the same hypothesis it follows that f is a constant on (,0) also. By continuity the constant values for x<0 and x>0 must be the same.


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find lim without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...