Wednesday, 27 July 2016

discrete mathematics - Show that f(S)cupf(T)subsetf(ScupT)



yf(S)f(T)x(ST)s.t.f(x)=y



x(ST)y=f(x)f(S)y=f(x)f(T)




y=f(x)f(ST)f(S)f(T)f(ST)



Ok, I don't have the intuition to prove things like this, so what can I do to develop that intuition?



I don't even really understand what I wrote.


Answer



The very first thing that I recommend is that you use more words and fewer symbols: it’s much easier to be clear on the logic if you explain it verbally as you go.



You have a function f:XY, say, and you want to show that if S,TX, then f[S]f[T]f[ST].




The most straightforward approach will work nicely: start with an arbitrary element of f[S]f[T], and show that it necessarily belongs to f[ST]. Here’s how that might look in practice:




Let yf[S]f[T]; then by the definition of union we know that yf[S] or yf[T]. Suppose first that yf[S]; then there is some xS such that f(x)=y. Of course SST, so xST, and therefore y=f(x)f[ST].



Now suppose instead that yf[T]; then there is some xT such that f(x)=y. Of course TST, so xST, and therefore y=f(x)f[ST]. In all cases, therefore, yf[ST], and since y was an arbitrary member of f[S]f[T], it follows that f[S]f[T]f[ST].




Once you really understand what you’re doing, you can shorten this quite a bit, but at this point, when you’re still feeling your way, it’s better to include too much detail than to include too little.



No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...