Sunday, 3 July 2016

real analysis - If f is continuous and fnrightarrowf uniformly on X as nrightarrowinfty



Let (X,dX) and (Y,dY) be metric spaces, let f:XY, and let (fn)n=1 be a sequence of functions fn:XY .



Prove or give a counterexample to the following statement:
If f is continuous and fnf uniformly on X as n, then there must exist some N1 such that fn is continuous for each nN.



I believe that the following statement is not true, and my counterexample lies within the following lines.




I know that it has to be something with 1n but I know we hvae to modify this a bit in order to account for the continuity, I would really appreciate some help in modifying my counterexample so it fully works, thank you!


Answer



Since you are looking for an counterexample, you can simplify the setting. For example, let be X=Y=R and dX and dY the euclidean metric.



Now, you can choose f to be constant, for example f0. Next, you can construction a sequence of function (fn)n=1 with an jump, which becomes 0 for n. Since each fn has a jump, they are all not continuous, while f is continouous.



One simple example for a sequence (fn)n=1 with fnf uniformly.





Define fn(x)={1nx>00x0




Or a bit more extreme example for a sequence (fn)n=1 with fnf uniformly.




Define fn(x)={1nxQ0xRQ In this example, fn is discontinuous everywhere for all nN, while f is continuous.



No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find lim without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...