I have managed to construct the following bound for e, which is defined as the unique positive number such that ∫e1dxx=1.
(1+1n)n≤e≤(nn−1)n
From here, there must surely be a way to deduce the well-known equality
limn→∞(1+1n)n=e
I have come up with the following, but I am not absolutely certain if this is correct or not.
PROPOSED SOLUTION:
The lower bound is fine as it is, so we shall leave it alone. Note that
(nn−1)n=(1+1n−1)n=(1+1n−1)n−1(1+1n−1)
So using the fact that the limit distributes over multiplication, we have
limn→∞(nn−1)n=limn→∞(1+1n−1)n−1limn→∞(1+1n−1)
Since limn→∞(1+1n−1)=1
and
limn→∞(1+1n−1)n−1=limm→∞(1+1m)m=e
We then have the required result
limn→∞(1+1n)n=e
Answer
The proof as stated is circular, but it's easily fixed, more or less by just rephrasing things.
Problem: When you say "Since ... lim(1+1m)m=e... we have the required result" you certainly appear to be assuming what you're trying to prove.
Fix: The original inequality shows that e≥lim sup(1+1n)n.
No comments:
Post a Comment