Monday, 29 August 2016

calculus - Problems with intinfty1fracsinxxdx convergence



I'd love your help with deciding whether the following integral converges or not and in what conditions: 1sinxx.



1. First, I wanted to use Dirichlet criterion: let f,g:[a,w)R integrable function, f is monotonic and g is continuous and fC1[a,w]. If in addition to these conditions, G(x)=xag(t) is bounded and limxwf(x)=0 so xafg converges. I can choose f=1x and g(x)=sinx, they applies all the conditions,(aren't they?) so why can't I use Dirichlet for this integral?




2. I used Wolfarm|Alpha and it says that 1sinxxdx does converge to π2 .is it only a conditional convergence? (and if so, does is count as non convergence?)



3. I was told that this integral does not absolute converges, meaning 1|sinx|xdx does not converges, How can I prove it?



Thanks a lot.


Answer



Jonas Meyer has already pointed out a link where the properties of this integral are discussed. However, I would like to show you an alternative proof that this integral does not converge absolutely (I saw this in Analysis I/II by Zorich and it doesn't seem as well-known as it should be imho):



The idea is simple. We first see that the only issue with convergence is at , since sin(x)x is continuous at 0.




Now 0|sin(x)|1 implies



|sin(x)|xsin2(x)x



And we note that 1sin2(x)xdx should essentially have the same convergence-properties as 1cos2(x)xdx (with some hand-waving at this point). But if this is true, then 0sin2(x)xdx converges if and only if 1(sin2(x)x+cos2(x)x)dx=1dxx


converges. The latter is clearly not true, so 0sin2(x)xdx doesn't converge, either.



More formally, we have




0|sin(x)|xdxπ/2sin2(x)xdx=0cos2(x)x+π/2dx



Hence



0|sin(x)|xdx120(sin2(x)x+cos2(x)x+π/2)dx=120(1x+π/2+π2sin2(x)x(x+π/2))dx1201x+π/2dx=


No comments:

Post a Comment

real analysis - How to find limhrightarrow0fracsin(ha)h

How to find limh0sin(ha)h without lhopital rule? I know when I use lhopital I easy get $$ \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}...