So we know that undefined values exist, like ln0. However, if you have eln0, it brings a problem where you can get 0, if you understand that e and lnx undo each other, or you will get undefined, because ln0 is undefined and e to an undefined value is undefined. So which is correct?
Another problem I have is with exponents. We know for example that if a−b=c, nanb=nc which works for example, if a is 3, b is 2, and n is 2, so 2322=2. But if n is 0, 0a−b is the same as 0a0b, which both values are 0 and the answer is undefined (or if you want to say 00 is 1, 1 still isn't 0), which would show that 0c (where c is any number) is undefined, since all numbers can be represented as a difference of two numbers.
In short:
My question is when do you simplify problems with undefined values (e.g 0201 is not 00 but instead just 01) and when is leaving it undefined correct? (e.g eln0 being undefined, not 0)
Answer
By the traditional meaning of equality, eln0 is undefined. You cannot 'cancel' ex and lnx because ln0 itself is undefined. It's analogous to rational functions like this:
(x−4)(x2+x+3)(x−4)
In the above function, you can cancel the term (x−4) on both the top and the bottom, but that doesn't change the fact the original function has a hole at x=4 because you're dividing by zero. Same concept here: you can 'cancel' ex and lnx, but that doesn't change the fact that it's undefined.
As you begin to venture into calculus and observe function behavior as x approaches some constant c, you can use limits to state that:
lim
So as x approaches 0 in e^{\ln{x}}, the expression tends to 0, but isn't equal in the traditional sense.
As for your concern about the power subtraction rule, it's simply restricted to nonzero values:
\dfrac{x^a}{x^b} = x^{a-b} \;\;\; x\neq0
So it's invalid to say:
\dfrac{0^2}{0^1} = 0^1 = 0
No comments:
Post a Comment