Every non-empty set A⊂N have a smallest element, i.e. an
element n0∈A such that n0≤n ∀n∈A
Proof:
Let In={p∈N;p≤n} the set of natural numbers less than or equal to n. If 1∈A then 1 will be the lower element. However if 1∉A then take X the set of natural numbers such that In⊂N−A. Knowing that I1= {1}⊂N−A then 1∈X. On the other hand knowing that A≠∅, we can conclude that X≠N. So there should be n∈X such that n+1∉X. Thus In={1,2,…,n}⊂N−A but n0=n+1∈A. Then n0 is the smaller element in A
Is there any easier way to prove it?
Answer
I would write it as:
Let P(n) stand for the expression:
∀x≤n(x∉A)
Then use the assumption that A has no least element to prove that P(1) and P(n)⟹P(n+1). Thus, we've shown that ∀x:x∉A, which means A is empty.
That's essentially the same as your proof, but uses less set notation.
No comments:
Post a Comment